Broil King vs Weber: Gas Grills Comparison [2021]

If you are looking for an awesome BBQ grill, there is a brand that you can rely on. The two big brands you can consider are Broil King and Weber. Both of these are top brands, but one has to know how they compare head to head.

In this article, we will compare these two grillers and get to know which wins in different categories and overall.

Broil King Brand History

The brand Broil King was founded in 1986. Its core product was making grills in the United States and Canada using readily available materials and local workers.

In 1999, the Broil King brand got absorbed by Cadco. Cadco is a massive manufacturer of high-end foodservice equipment and, this allowed them to expand the range of their grills exponentially.

Weber Brand History

Weber is by far the most recognizable brand in the barbeque market. It was founded in 1952 in Chicago. The first Weber grill was made by George Stephen Sr. from one half of a marine buoy, offering it that distinctive hemispherical Weber look that is visible in some iconic smokers.

Since then, the brand has expanded from producing simple brazier grills to a wide array of equipment.

Broil King and Weber Comparison

To make a thorough comparison, we will get down to the features of each one.

Cooking System

In both models, cooking systems are installed in the grills. There are models of the Weber cooking system. Some utilize combinations of flame tamers and flavorizers.

They help in the distribution of heat, reducing flare-ups and directing drippings away from the burner. They then vaporize them away to enhance the flavor.

Broil King models come with the Flav-R-Heat partitions and the Flav-R-Wave cooking system that is made of stainless steel. What the Flav-R-Heat Partitions do is that they separate off the individual burners and allow you to cook food in different areas at different temperatures.

The cooking system of the Broil King models is quite similar to the Weber cooking System.

The similarity comes in that they both prevent drips from the food falling directly into the burners. They ensure that the drips are diverted onto the stainless steel bars that ultimately vaporize them.

Both cooking systems are great. However, the Weber cooking system will bring the added benefit of allowing your partition off areas of your cook box and also allow you to cook at different temperatures.

Cooking Surface

To compare the cooking surface area, we will look at a model of each brand. For instance, the Broil King (Sovereign XLS 90) is a large grill and, at the same time, has a large cooking area.

If you pay some attention to its cook box, it covers a 600-inch area. Now, if you add that to the 400 inches of the rotisserie and burner, it is a total of up to 1,000 square inches.

If we look at the Weber model (Genesis E-435), you will note that it has a cooking surface area of 646 square inches. It has an additional 145 inches for the burner. It brings the total coverage of the cooking surface to 844 square inches.

Although it may look like the Broil King model has the upper hand in this category, one should note that about 200 square inches of the cooking surface are a rotisserie that is not as essential as a side burner. If by chance you remove the rotisserie, both of the grills will have the same cooking areas.

However, the Broil King is still a larger grill. For someone who may not require to use the rotisserie, the Weber will offer an extra cooking space. In this category, the race is pretty close.

Warranty

When it comes to warranty, both the Broil King and Weber models are close. Both models come with some good warranties.

If we look at the Weber model like the Genesis II E-435, you will realize that it comes with a 10-year warranty covering any defects on workmanship and material. It is worth noting that wear and tear are not covered.

Moving on to the Broil King models, you will note that they offer a slightly less encompassing and more granular warranty. They offer a 10-year warranty on the burners and cook box.

Customers will also enjoy a 5-year warranty on the stainless steel Flav-R-Wave cooking system, the grates, and an additional two-year warranty on all other parts as well as the paint.

As we can see, the Broil King guarantee is more impressive for its comprehensive nature and is pretty standard for a high-end grill, it cannot outdo the Webers simply because of its decade worth of warranty covering individual components of their grills.

Burners/BTU Output

To compare these two brands based on BTU output/ Burners, we will look at one model for each. The Weber Genesis comes with four high-end stainless steel burners on its primary cooking surface that generate a combined 48,000 BTUs of power.

In addition to that, it features a shelf-mounted burner that effectively puts out around 12,000 BTUs and 9,000 BTUs searing stations for a total of 69,000 BTUs combined output.

The Weber burners have a triangular shape that narrows towards the back of the grill. It enhances the production of consistent heat across the cooking surface. At the same time, it cuts down the output of the main burner.

Top 3 Weber Grill Reviews

1. Weber 62006001 Genesis II S-435 4-Burner Liquid Propane Grill

The Weber 62006001 Genesis II S-435 4-Burner Liquid Propane Grill features stainless steel flavorizer bars, a management system of grease, and infinity ignition.

It is a high-performance grilling system with four burners, one side burner, and one sear station with 69,000 BTUs of combined output. You can prepare more food using the grill since it has a large cooking surface plus a tuck-away warming rack.

The cooking grates allow even heat distribution and superior heat retention since it has a stainless lid. Your grill is also protected from outside elements. You can comfortably check the grill temperature through your mobile phone. IGrill 3 app-connected thermometer monitors your food from the start to the end.

The grill has a storage cabinet to keep all your tools and accessories. With an easy-to-read fuel gauge, you can view the fuel level, and your cooking will not be cut short. Enjoy your grilling with a ten-year warranty for weber genesis.

Pros
  • Has a large cooking space
  • Available in both natural and propane gas
  • High heat output
  • Durable
Cons
  • A bit expensive

2. Weber Summit 7270001 S-470 Stainless-Steel Natural-Gas Grill

For grill masters, the Weber Summit 7270001 S-470 Stainless-Steel Natural-Gas Grill is a perfect choice to satisfy your grilling needs. It is a natural gas unit and, you must have the natural gas plumbed out to your deck or patio for you to grill.

The grill features four stainless-steel burners, each with its snap-jet ignition. The burner has an output of 48,800 BTU per hour which is enough heat to grill more food.

With a cooking area of 468 square inches and 112 square inches of warmings rack, it provides a large working area. Cooking grates, shroud, and flavorizer bars are made of durable heavy-duty stainless steel. The sear station will offer a perfect finish to your meat.

Other features include an enclosed cart, grill-out light 10-foot flexible hose, and 6 tool hooks. You have enough space to keep or hang your grilling tools and a thermometer to check the temperatures. An integrated smoker box and a tuck-away rotisserie LED illuminated burner knobs are some of the additional features to make your grilling easy. With five years warranty, you are assured of a quality grilling experience.

Pros
  • Has four burners: smoker burner, sear station burner, side burner, and rotisserie burner
  • Has a great stainless steel design
  • Durable
Cons
  • A bit expensive

3. Weber Original Kettle Premium Charcoal Grill

Most grilling enthusiasts use charcoal to make the best grill steak. Weber Original Kettle Premium Charcoal Grill is one of the best charcoal grills

Features a 22-inch diameter and a cooking area of 363 square inches, it is enough to hold 13 burgers. The lid and bowl are porcelain-enameled for heat retention and to prevent corrosion.

The lid has a built-in thermometer where you can monitor the temperature as you grill. A rust-resistant aluminum damper is also available for precision heat control. It is easy to adjust the dampers without opening the lid, and closing the lid extinguishes the charcoal.

You can easily add charcoal to the grill since the grates have a hinged design. Save your time by hanging the lid on the angled lid hook on the side of the grill. It is convenient instead of placing the lid on the ground.

Place your grilling tools on the hooks for easy access and to make your workplace organized. The grill can withstand high temperatures. Cleaning is troublesome after grilling, but with this grill, you can worry less.

It has a one-touch cleaning system that sweeps the ash and debris into a removable large-capacity container. Moving from place to place is eased by durable wheels.

Pros
  • Has compact design
  • Cost friendly
  • Ash catcher provides easy ash cleanup
Cons
  • Has a small to medium coking space

Top 3 Broil King Grill Reviews

1. Broil King 911470 Keg 5000 Kamado Grill

To make the perfect tasty charcoal grill, use the Broil King 911470 Keg 5000 Kamado Grill. Its body has a double-walled steel grill and oven-grade insulation. As a result, the heat does not escape and maximizes your fuel efficiency to delicious food.

You can grill more food at a go using the grill at a go. It has a primary cooking area of 280 square inches and a second working area of 200 square inches. 480 square inches is a sufficient space to make food for a large family.

Take control of your grill’s temperature by using roto draft dampers at the bottom and top. Regulate the airflow to attain the desired temperature for the grill. The grill has side shelves to keep your cooking tools and essentials at an arm’s reach.

With the mess that comes with grilling, the grill has a removable ash catcher to collect ash. The amount of charcoal used in the grill is twice less than that used in the normal grill, hence saving money.

Pros
  • Uses less fuel
  • Durable
  • Easy to clean
  • Can be mounted on your car to travel with it
Cons
  • It is hard to keep at a constant temperature

2. Broil King 956217 Regal 420 Pro NG Gas Grill

The Broil King 956217 Regal 420 Pro NG Gas Grill is a great grill to make the perfect steak. It features an innovative Flav-R-Wave stainless steel cooking system and a patented stainless steel Dual-Tube burner.

These incredible features ensure that temperatures are spread evenly across the cooking surface making the meat delicious and juicy. The grill comes with durable cooking grids.

They are 9mm stainless steel cooking grids that are about 50% heavier than the common grids. They can retain heat for a long time making the griller effective.

The grill has some additional features that make it even more convenient to ensure that the grilling experience is wonderful. It has a cabinet shelf with space to store your grilling equipment. 

The cool knobs allow you to have a clear view of the parts of your grill that allow you to create a beautiful glow in your outdoor grilling space. This grill comes with a decade worth of limited warranty on burners, Flav-R-Wave, and cooking grids.

The rest of the parts come with a two-year warranty as well as the paint. Any buyer is assured of the quality of the grill and it will serve them for years.

Pros
  • It is durable
  • It is easy to use
  • It spreads even temperatures across the cooking surface
  • It comes with a 10-year limited warranty
Cons
  • The burners can rust if not well maintained

3. Broil King 958944 Regal S590 Pro IR Propane Gas Grill

The Broil King 958944 Regal S590 Pro IR Propane Gas Grill comes with a ceramic infrared side burner that can instantly reach high temperatures beyond a thousand degrees. These temperatures help in getting the right flavor on the meat quickly.

Its side burners come with a steel grid rod made of stainless steel. It has the Flav-R-Wave stainless steel and is patented with the stainless Dual-Tube burners.

It can provide even temperatures across the cooking surface thus resulting in a sweet steak. 

The cooking grids are made of stainless steel and measure 9mm. They are heavier than other comparable grills and at the same time provide proper heat retention. The stainless steel ensures that it lasts for an extended time.

It features LED knobs that enhance the visibility of all the controls on the grill. It also provides beautiful scenery and adds glamour to the outdoor patio space.

The Broil King 958944 grill comes with a ten-year limited warranty on the Flav-R-Wave, cooking grids, and burners. The rest of the parts have a two-year warranty on them. 

Pros
  • It is durable
  • Easy to use
  • It has a large cooking space
Cons
  • Some of its parts rust quickly

Final Verdict

If you are looking for a grill that will allow you to cook the best meat of your life, then there are two brands that you can consider. Both Weber and Broil King have earned a lot of respect and admirers for their grills.

Broil King and Weber each have their own tempting benefits that one can enjoy. One has to be sure that they know how to make the right choice between these two brands. Personal preference and other factors are important as well.

However, Broil King grills have the extra features that give them an upper hand.

If you are searching for a gas grill, consider the ones discussed above. You will take your grilling game to a whole new level.